If you’re someone who enjoys a good cocktail with a unique twist, the S’mores Old Fashioned is sure to intrigue you. This creative and indulgent drink combines the nostalgic flavors of a campfire treat—s’mores—with the timeless elegance of the Old Fashioned cocktail. For those who love both classic drinks and the comforting, sweet combination of chocolate, marshmallows, and graham crackers, this drink offers the best of both worlds.

In this article, we will explore everything you need to know about the S’mores Old Fashioned: its origins, ingredients, preparation methods, variations, and why it’s the perfect drink for any occasion. Whether you’re looking to create this cocktail at home or want to try it out at your local bar, we’ve got all the information you need.

What is a S’mores Old Fashioned Cocktail?

The S’mores Old Fashioned cocktail is a clever and delightful variation of the classic Old Fashioned. Traditionally, an Old Fashioned is a whiskey-based cocktail made with muddled sugar, bitters, and a twist of citrus peel, garnished with a cherry or orange slice. It’s a sophisticated drink with a smooth balance of sweet and bitter flavors, typically made with bourbon or rye whiskey.

The S’mores Old Fashioned, however, takes this classic foundation and adds an unexpected twist by incorporating the flavors of s’mores. Inspired by the traditional campfire dessert, the drink combines whiskey with marshmallow syrup, chocolate bitters, and graham cracker elements. This creates a cocktail that perfectly mimics the sweet, smoky, and satisfying flavors of a s’mores treat.

But why has this drink become so popular? The S’mores Old Fashioned taps into the modern trend of cocktail experimentation. People enjoy seeing familiar ingredients being transformed into something new and exciting, and this hybrid drink offers a familiar flavor profile that many are already fond of, thanks to the classic s’mores dessert. Additionally, it’s the perfect drink for a themed evening, a seasonal event, or even a cozy winter gathering.

Why is the S’mores Old Fashioned Popular?

The rise of creative cocktail recipes has been a defining trend in the beverage industry in recent years. Bartenders are increasingly pushing boundaries by fusing different flavor profiles, textures, and spirits. S’mores Old Fashioned is an example of how a traditional drink can be updated with modern ingredients and an unexpected flavor profile.

People love nostalgia, and the s’mores flavor combination brings back fond memories of summer nights spent around a campfire. The drink serves as both a comfort and a treat, evoking that sense of warmth and togetherness. But it’s also a cocktail with depth, sophistication, and complexity—qualities that the Old Fashioned itself is known for.

In addition, the S’mores Old Fashioned appeals to those who enjoy dessert cocktails. It’s sweet, but not overly sugary, and offers a balanced, flavorful experience. Whether served at a dinner party, a holiday gathering, or just for a cozy evening, the cocktail is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Ingredients for Making a S’mores Old Fashioned

To make a S’mores Old Fashioned, you’ll need some essential ingredients that blend the flavors of s’mores with the structure of a traditional Old Fashioned cocktail. Let’s take a closer look at what you need to create this delicious drink.

What You’ll Need:

  1. Whiskey (Bourbon or Rye): The base of the Old Fashioned is whiskey, and you’ll want a smooth, flavorful bourbon or rye whiskey. Bourbon is often favored because of its sweeter, caramel notes that complement the s’mores flavor profile.
  2. Simple Syrup: A bit of sweetness is key to the Old Fashioned, and simple syrup (made from sugar and water) is a must. You can adjust the amount based on how sweet you want the drink.
  3. Chocolate Bitters: Bitters are an essential ingredient in an Old Fashioned. In this version, chocolate bitters are used to bring out the chocolatey depth of the s’mores.
  4. Marshmallow Syrup (or Toasted Marshmallows): Marshmallow syrup is an easy way to bring that toasted marshmallow flavor into the drink. If you prefer, you can also toast marshmallows over a flame and add the essence of that toasted sweetness by incorporating a small amount of toasted marshmallow syrup.
  5. Graham Cracker Crumbs: To mimic the graham cracker element of a s’more, you’ll need graham cracker crumbs. You can rim the glass with crushed graham crackers for a decorative touch and extra flavor.
  6. Ice: Use large ice cubes for an Old Fashioned, as they melt slowly and won’t dilute the drink too quickly.
  7. Garnishes: A toasted marshmallow (or marshmallow fluff) for garnish can add an extra element of fun. Some variations also include a small piece of chocolate or even a graham cracker wedge.

Alternative Variations of Ingredients:

If you’re looking for variations on the ingredients, there are some options for making this drink fit dietary preferences or simply changing things up:

  • Vegan Marshmallows: For those who prefer a plant-based version, you can use vegan marshmallows or marshmallow fluff. These are available at most specialty grocery stores or health food markets.
  • Gluten-Free Graham Crackers: If you need a gluten-free option, simply substitute regular graham crackers with gluten-free ones. Many brands offer a similar taste and texture.
  • Flavored Whiskeys: Some variations of the S’mores Old Fashioned incorporate flavored whiskeys, such as maple or cinnamon. These can give the drink an extra layer of flavor that pairs beautifully with the s’mores elements.

How to Make a S’mores Old Fashioned Cocktail

Now that you know what ingredients are needed, let’s go over the steps to make a S’mores Old Fashioned. While it might seem a little complex at first, it’s really quite simple once you break it down.

Step-by-Step Instructions:

  1. Prepare the Glass: Start by preparing the glass. You can either rim the glass with crushed graham crackers or toast a marshmallow on a skewer to give it that roasted, campfire flavor. The graham cracker rim adds a lovely crunch and sweetness, while the marshmallow gives a fun and authentic touch.
  2. Mix the Cocktail: In a mixing glass, combine 2 ounces of bourbon or rye whiskey, 1/4 ounce of simple syrup, and a dash of chocolate bitters. If you’re using marshmallow syrup, add 1/4 ounce of that as well. Stir the ingredients with ice until well chilled.
  3. Strain and Serve: Strain the mixture into a glass filled with a large ice cube. You want the ice cube to melt slowly so the drink doesn’t become watered down too quickly.
  4. Garnish: Now for the fun part! Toast a marshmallow using a kitchen torch or over an open flame, and carefully place it on top of the drink. If you’ve rimmed your glass with graham crackers, the garnish will stay in place, giving it a beautiful and indulgent look. You can also sprinkle graham cracker crumbs over the drink or place a small wedge of chocolate as an additional garnish.

Pro Tips for a Perfect S’mores Old Fashioned:

  • Balance is Key: The sweetness of the marshmallow syrup and chocolate bitters should complement, not overpower, the whiskey. Taste as you go and adjust the syrup or bitters to your preference.
  • Smoke It: For added depth, consider using a smoking gun to infuse the drink with a light smoky flavor, which mimics the experience of roasting marshmallows over an open fire.
  • Quality Ingredients Matter: Since this cocktail relies on just a few key ingredients, choosing high-quality whiskey and chocolate bitters will make a noticeable difference in flavor

Variations of the S’mores Old Fashioned

While the classic S’mores Old Fashioned recipe is already a treat for the taste buds, there are several variations you can try. Each variation brings a new twist on the beloved flavors of s’mores, allowing you to customize the cocktail to your liking.

1. Smoked S’mores Old Fashioned

One of the most exciting variations of the S’mores Old Fashioned is the smoked version. This twist adds a layer of smokiness to the drink, further enhancing the connection to the campfire experience. There are a couple of ways to achieve this effect:

  • Using a Smoking Gun: A smoking gun is a handy device that infuses smoke into a drink or glass. You can use it to add a smokey aroma and flavor to the cocktail before serving. Simply place the smoking gun in the glass and let the smoke infuse the drink. This method adds a rich, campfire-like quality to your S’mores Old Fashioned.
  • Smoked Ice: Another way to bring smoke into your drink is by using smoked ice cubes. To make them, you can place ice cubes on a smoker tray or in a closed container with wood chips, letting them absorb the smoke. When added to your cocktail, the smoked ice cubes provide a subtle smoky flavor as they melt.

This variation is perfect for those who want an even more authentic s’mores experience—complete with the smoky aroma and flavors of a real campfire.

2. Spicy S’mores Old Fashioned

If you enjoy a little heat with your sweetness, the spicy version of the S’mores Old Fashioned is an excellent choice. To add some spice, simply infuse the simple syrup with a chili pepper or add a small dash of cayenne pepper to the mix. The heat from the spice creates an interesting contrast with the rich sweetness of the marshmallow syrup and chocolate bitters.

Alternatively, you can swap out the whiskey for a spiced rum or cinnamon whiskey, which will add a warm, zesty undertone to the drink. A garnish of candied ginger or a spicy rim (using chili powder or cinnamon) can also elevate the flavor profile.

3. Vegan S’mores Old Fashioned

For those following a vegan lifestyle, it’s possible to create a plant-based version of the S’mores Old Fashioned. Replace the marshmallow syrup with a vegan marshmallow fluff or marshmallow syrup. Many brands offer vegan alternatives to traditional marshmallows that contain no gelatin or animal products.

Additionally, ensure that the whiskey you choose is vegan-friendly. Most spirits are vegan, but it’s always best to check the label or do some research. There are also vegan versions of chocolate bitters available if you’re looking for a completely plant-based cocktail.

This variation allows vegans and those with dietary restrictions to enjoy the delicious flavors of s’mores without compromising on their values.

4. Fruity S’mores Old Fashioned

For a lighter, fruit-infused twist, you can incorporate fruits into your S’mores Old Fashioned. Adding muddled berries (such as raspberries or blackberries) or a splash of fruit syrup can bring a touch of brightness and tartness to the drink, balancing out the sweetness from the marshmallow syrup and chocolate bitters.

A fruit garnish, such as a skewer of fresh fruit or a citrus peel, can also be added to the drink for extra flair and flavor. This variation works particularly well in the summertime or for occasions when you want a cocktail with a fresher, fruitier vibe.

Pairing the S’mores Old Fashioned with Food

One of the best parts of any cocktail is enjoying it with delicious food, and the S’mores Old Fashioned is no exception. The unique combination of chocolate, marshmallow, and graham cracker flavors lends itself well to several food pairings that will elevate your drinking experience.

1. Charcuterie Boards

A charcuterie board with a variety of cheeses, cured meats, crackers, and fresh fruits pairs wonderfully with the S’mores Old Fashioned. The rich, savory flavors of the meats and cheeses provide a nice contrast to the sweet and smoky notes of the cocktail. Look for cheeses like brie, gouda, or cheddar to balance the drink’s sweetness. Adding a few sweet elements like figs or honey will also complement the s’mores flavors.

2. S’mores-Themed Desserts

What better way to pair the S’mores Old Fashioned than with actual s’mores-inspired desserts? S’mores cupcakes, s’mores cheesecake, or even traditional s’mores made over an open flame can be a perfect pairing. The combination of chocolate, marshmallow, and graham crackers in the dessert mirrors the flavors in the drink, creating a harmonious experience.

If you’re feeling creative, you can even make a S’mores Old Fashioned float by serving it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The ice cream melts into the drink, adding a creamy texture and additional sweetness that is simply delightful.

3. Grilled Meats

The smoky flavors of grilled meats, such as barbecued ribs, steaks, or even grilled chicken, pair exceptionally well with the S’mores Old Fashioned. The sweetness of the cocktail balances out the charred and savory flavors of grilled foods, creating a complex and satisfying combination. Serve your grilled meats with sides like roasted vegetables or corn on the cob for a complete meal.

4. Chocolate-Based Treats

Since the S’mores Old Fashioned has chocolate bitters as one of its key ingredients, pairing it with chocolate-based desserts or treats is a natural choice. Think chocolate truffles, brownies, or a rich chocolate mousse. The chocolatey goodness in both the cocktail and the dessert creates an indulgent, decadent experience that’s perfect for any chocolate lover.

Occasions for Enjoying a S’mores Old Fashioned

The S’mores Old Fashioned is a versatile cocktail that can be enjoyed on various occasions. Whether you’re hosting a special event or simply relaxing at home, this drink adds a touch of warmth and indulgence to any gathering.

1. Seasonal Gatherings (Fall and Winter)

The cozy, comforting flavors of the S’mores Old Fashioned make it an ideal drink for seasonal gatherings, especially during the fall and winter months. Imagine sipping on this rich cocktail by a roaring fireplace, surrounded by friends or family during the holidays. Its warming qualities make it perfect for chilly evenings when you want to enjoy a drink that brings a sense of comfort and nostalgia.

2. Summer BBQs and Campfire Nights

If you’re hosting a summer BBQ or gathering around a campfire, the S’mores Old Fashioned is a fantastic cocktail to serve. The connection to traditional s’mores makes it a fun and thematic drink for campfire parties, especially if you’re roasting marshmallows and making s’mores with friends. This drink is sure to be a hit when paired with grilled meats, smoky cocktails, and lots of laughter.

3. Holiday Celebrations (Christmas, Thanksgiving, etc.)

For holiday gatherings like Christmas, Thanksgiving, or even New Year’s Eve, the S’mores Old Fashioned makes an excellent cocktail for celebrations. Its warm flavors are comforting and festive, making it the perfect drink to serve alongside holiday dinners or desserts. The s’mores theme ties in beautifully with the cozy, family-oriented spirit of these holidays.

4. Cocktail Parties

If you’re hosting a cocktail party and want to impress your guests with something unique, the S’mores Old Fashioned will certainly stand out. Its combination of sophistication and fun makes it a conversation starter. Serve it alongside other creative cocktails, and watch as your guests rave about the delicious and unexpected flavors.

Conclusion

The S’mores Old Fashioned is an excellent example of how traditional cocktails can be reimagined with modern twists. By blending the rich, timeless flavors of a classic Old Fashioned with the comforting, nostalgic taste of s’mores, this drink brings together the best of both worlds. Whether you’re enjoying it at a cozy winter gathering, pairing it with delicious desserts, or serving it at a special occasion, the S’mores Old Fashioned offers an indulgent and fun way to elevate your cocktail game.

With so many variations to explore and endless possibilities for food pairings, the S’mores Old Fashioned is a drink that will never go out of style. So why not mix up this delicious twist on a classic cocktail the next time you’re looking to impress your guests or treat yourself to something sweet and smoky? Cheers!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about S’mores Old Fashioned

1. What is a S’mores Old Fashioned?

A S’mores Old Fashioned is a creative twist on the classic Old Fashioned cocktail, incorporating the flavors of a traditional s’mores treat. It combines whiskey, marshmallow syrup, chocolate bitters, and a graham cracker garnish to create a sweet, smoky, and indulgent drink that evokes the nostalgic flavors of campfire s’mores.

2. Can I make a non-alcoholic version of a S’mores Old Fashioned?

Yes, you can make a non-alcoholic version of the S’mores Old Fashioned by substituting the whiskey with a non-alcoholic spirit or by using a flavored soda like cola or root beer. You can still keep the marshmallow syrup, chocolate bitters, and graham cracker garnish for the same rich, sweet flavor profile.

3. Can I use regular marshmallows instead of marshmallow syrup?

While you can use regular marshmallows, marshmallow syrup is recommended for a smooth consistency and ease of mixing. To make homemade marshmallow syrup, you can melt marshmallows with a bit of water or simple syrup, then strain to remove any solid bits.

4. How can I make my own marshmallow syrup?

To make homemade marshmallow syrup, combine about 1 cup of marshmallows with 1/2 cup of water over low heat. Stir until the marshmallows are fully melted and the syrup has thickened. You can also add a bit of vanilla extract for extra flavor. Once cooled, strain the syrup and it’s ready to use in your S’mores Old Fashioned.

5. Can I use a different whiskey in the S’mores Old Fashioned?

Absolutely! While bourbon is commonly used in the S’mores Old Fashioned due to its rich, caramel notes, you can use any whiskey of your choice. Rye whiskey will give the cocktail a spicier edge, while a smooth Irish whiskey can add a lighter, more delicate flavor. Experiment to find the whiskey that suits your taste best.

6. What can I use instead of chocolate bitters?

If you don’t have chocolate bitters, you can substitute them with regular Angostura bitters and a small splash of chocolate syrup or cocoa powder. However, chocolate bitters are specifically formulated to bring the right balance of bitterness and chocolate flavor, so using the real thing is recommended for the best taste.

7. Can I make the S’mores Old Fashioned ahead of time?

You can prepare the components of the cocktail ahead of time, such as the marshmallow syrup and chocolate bitters, and store them in the fridge. However, it’s best to mix the cocktail right before serving to ensure the fresh flavors and presentation are at their peak.

8. How can I make a smoked S’mores Old Fashioned?

To make a smoked version of the S’mores Old Fashioned, you can use a smoking gun to infuse the drink with smoke just before serving. Alternatively, you can smoke the ice cubes by placing them on a smoker tray and allowing them to absorb the smoke, then use them to chill your cocktail.

9. What foods pair well with a S’mores Old Fashioned?

The S’mores Old Fashioned pairs wonderfully with savory and sweet foods. For savory options, try pairing it with a charcuterie board, grilled meats, or roasted vegetables. For sweet treats, s’mores cupcakes, chocolate-based desserts, or traditional s’mores are great matches.

10. Can I make a vegan version of the S’mores Old Fashioned?

Yes, you can make a vegan version by substituting the marshmallow syrup with a vegan marshmallow fluff or syrup. Also, make sure the whiskey you choose is vegan-friendly, as some whiskeys may use animal products in the filtering process. Vegan chocolate bitters are also available for a completely plant-based drink.

11. What is the best occasion for serving a S’mores Old Fashioned?

The S’mores Old Fashioned is perfect for a variety of occasions. It’s ideal for cozy gatherings during the fall and winter months, as its warm, comforting flavors fit the season. It also works well for summer BBQs, campfire nights, and holiday celebrations like Christmas or Thanksgiving. It’s a great conversation starter for cocktail parties as well!

12. Can I adjust the sweetness of the S’mores Old Fashioned?

Yes, you can adjust the sweetness by adding more or less marshmallow syrup to the cocktail. If you prefer a less sweet drink, start with a smaller amount of syrup and taste as you go. You can also use a bitters-heavy approach if you want the sweetness to be more balanced with a deeper, more complex flavor profile.

13. Is the S’mores Old Fashioned kid-friendly?

No, the S’mores Old Fashioned is an alcoholic cocktail and is not suitable for children. However, you can make a kid-friendly version by omitting the whiskey and replacing it with a non-alcoholic beverage like a flavored soda or fruit juice. Keep the marshmallow syrup and chocolate flavors to maintain the essence of the drink.

14. How can I store leftover marshmallow syrup?

Leftover marshmallow syrup can be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week. You can use it in other cocktails or even drizzle it over desserts like ice cream or pancakes.